Illustration by Zohar LazarIn the July/August 2014 problem of The Atlantic Sarah Boxer wonders “Why Are All the Cartoon Mothers Dead?”

And they are, you know. Bambi, Nemo, Scurrently White, Ariel, Belle, Pocahontas, Aladdin, and virtually any various other cartoon major character you deserve to think of is a mothermuch less boy. In reality, Ms Boxer obstacles her readers to “display me an animated kids’ movie that has actually a called mommy in it who resides until the credits roll.” There aren’t that many kind of. The Lion King, Coraline, The Incredibles and also a couple of others concerned mind.

You are watching: Why are all the cartoon mothers dead

However before, she doesn’t try extremely hard to answer her own evocative question. She offers a few lame answers like:

The unfolding of plot and personality relies on the dead mom.*The dead mommy is psychologically great for the child because it enables him/her to maintain an internal great mom (even if the herbal mother hadn’t been all good) and allows him/her to direct all his anger at the action mother.**

I can think of much better answers than that!

As a writer, it’s evident to me that youngsters through living, loving parents are unlikely to be out in the cold having exciting adendeavors. They are at home discovering exactly how to be happy, abundant members of society. And then there is the initially commandment of fiction: “Torture thy Protagonist.” One of the cruelest points you deserve to execute to a son is take ameans his/her mommy.

And as a pagan, it’s obvious to me that The Dead Mvarious other is a metaphor for the state of modern Western Civilization. Judaism, then Christianity, and also last yet not leastern, Islam have all taken amethod our Mother. It was easy for them bereason these leading faiths of Western Civilization are all monotheistic, and each of their gods is a guy. And they are all manly guys, stern fathers who expect single minded devotion from their followers. In a nutshell, that’s a simplistic explanation of what happened to the Goddesses of Western Civilization.*** This connect on the Goddess in Christianity and also Mary Magdelene provides some quick background indevelopment on a topic that that can fill a library.****

I have the right to name just one still flourishing, universally popular goddess; the exemption to the Dead Mvarious other syndrome that proves my allude by portraying how a lot we require our Mothers. The Blessed Virgin Mary is the goddess that the Catholic Church hasn’t managed to do amethod with. Of course, the Church denies up one side and also down the other that she is magnificent, (see previous post: “The Virgin Mary, Isis, The High Priestess, and the Empress”) but you’d never before recognize it from the way Catholics and a fair variety of non-Catholics the people over worship her, and the amount of fabulous art devoted to her. When we were in Italy it appeared choose eextremely various other block had actually carefully tfinished, flower bedecked BVM shrine. The Lady is absolutely satisfying a strong require that the stern patriarchs of monotheism and also sweet Jesus can’t.

And simply what is the attractivity of the Mother? Well, let’s put it this way: A involved Mama minute is a lot even more comforting and also nurturing than a concerned Jesus minute. Both have their area, but our lives are challenging and painful and also we require comfort and also knowledge more frequently than we need the difficult facts of life shoved in our challenge. The Goddess nourishes our emotional, intuitive, imaginative, and also magical sides, and in a mostly God based society this doesn’t occur practically often enough. As an outcome we tfinish to ignore our children and elders, live in emotional isolation from each other, fight wars at the drop of a helmet, pollute the earth, and value money over soul.

There, I’m done ranting. To me it’s a no brainer. The Cartoon Mothers are dead because our society has actually killed its own mother. Kill a child’s Mother and you develop pain and conflict in that child’s heart. Kill the Mother in a story and you have a plot that resonates strongly with our society.

I would have actually collection the short article aside at this point if Ms Boxer hadn’t asked a second even even more intriguing question: Why have children’s movie machines not just continued to kill off the Mvarious other, but have actually additionally reput the wicked action mommy with—ta da!—the perfect Father? To quote M

Marlin, Nemo’s ultimately perfect father

s Boxer: “He may begin out hyperimportant (Chicken Little) or reluctant (Ice Age). He might be a tyrant (The Little Mermaid) or a ne’er-do-well (Despicable Me). He might be of the wrong species (Kung Fu Panda). He may also be the killer of the child’s mom (Brvarious other Bear). No issue exactly how negative he starts out, though, he constantly ends up good…

Quite simply, mothers are eliminated in today’s kids’ movies so the fathers deserve to take over…The old fairy-tale, family-romance movies that pitted negative motherless youngsters against horrible vengeful stepmothers are a point of the previous. Now plucky children and their plucky fathers join pressures to make their method in a motherless people. The orphan plot of yore seems to have morphed, over the past decade, right into the buddy plot of today. Roll over, Freud: in a neat reversal of the Oedipus complex, the mommy is eliminated so that the kids have the right to have actually the father to themselves. Sure, womales and girls may come and also go, even take part in the adventure, yet mothers? Not permitted. And you know what? It looks like fun!”

 Ms Boxer goes on to suggest that this trend is a last, despeprice, chauvinistic attempt to recreate a kinder, gentler patriarchy. She is chillingly convincing. As a disturbing exhilittle A she directs our attention to the movie Barnyard (Paramount/Nickelodeon, 2006), in which Ben, a father bull teaches his ne’er-do-well, motherless child, Otis, just how to be a male. In this movie, when a bull stands up on his hind legs prefer a human, instead of the intended extremely Full Monty, he flashes a significant, pink, complete udder. Yes you review that right; I’ve even contained a photo for your further elucidation. The message of this flick appears blatantly obvious. Who requirements a mother? Men have it all.

But this conclusion doesn’t feel best to me. I’m not prepared to label Disney Studios and the rest of the children’s movie sector as male chauvinist pigs. The early on Disney Movies were mostly fairy tales and also fairy tales are fundamentally individual tales that have been told and also retold. In various other words they are old and also most likely predate Christianity. In other words, they are pagan with Christian overtones. The goddess shows up in these movies in three develops, the triple goddess of modern witches. She is the maiden (typically the heroine), the mother (generally dead because the Christians killed the mom goddess) and the crone (generally the wicked witch or evil sorceress—the goddess is tough to kill totally, however simple to demonize). So the first successful children’s movies began via this formula, and Hollyhardwood is loathe to component with a effective formula. It gets used over and also over and also over again. Thus we have all the dead mothers and hapmuch less heroines and wicked female villains in children’s literature and also movies. And you gotta admit, Disney had some knock-your-socks-off female villains. Definitely strong feminine role models. They are my favorite Disney characters.

Maleficent, in “Sleeping Beauty”

Margaret Starbird pushes this idea a bit additionally. (watch link) She claims that Ariel, Disney’s Little Mermassist, “is much more than a fairytale for little bit girls. Rather, she is a powerful metaphore for the plight of the “Sacred Feminine” over the last several thousand years of western people.” Ariel is Mary Magdelene, the shed bride of Christianity, who has actually increased up from the watery depths of our subaware and onto dry, logical land. “It is interesting to

note,” says Ms Starbird, “that in the Disney film, it is not Ariel that needs to be conserved, but rather it is the “handsome Prince” that is in deep trouble, shipwrecked and dying (the problem of the partriarchy at the dawn of Aquarius??)” Interelaxing, I thought, but she appears to be extending it a bit. But then I came upon what for me was the clincher in her argument. Ariel collects many type of human artifacts and one of her special treasures is a painting. Now of all the possible functions of western art Disney studios can have actually preferred to portray, they chose a painting by Georges de la Tour called “Magdalen through the Smoking Flame.” Perhaps tbelow is an underlying message in The Little Mermhelp after all; if so, it is distinctly feminist and also definitely not patriarchal.

If we begin with my premise that the Mother is dead in children’s movies (and additionally fairly a little bit of Western Literature) bereason the Goddess was removed from our culture through the advent of the patriarchal monotheistic religious beliefs, we can restructure the concern of the perfect father and also involved a different conclusion.

In the USA, the Goddess is alive and also coming to be stronger eexceptionally day. According to the US Census Bureau the number of witches willing to come out of the broom closet and actually admit to being witches has actually enhanced astronomically. They estimate that in 1990 one in eexceptionally 22,000 Americans was a witch, but in 2008 one in eincredibly 667 Americans was a witch, and also I have no doubt that the number is even better this day. And this is just witches, not neopagans, Asatru, Hindu, Unitarian/Universalist, or various other Goddess worshipping faiths. Christianity still dominates our culture, yet the numbers are decreasing slightly. In 1990 one in eextremely 1.16 people shelp they were Christian and in 2008, the number dropped to one in eextremely 1.32 world. This number, of course, contains Catholics that, as I have shown, actually perform worship the goddess in the form of the BVM, and all the various other Christians that include the Goddess in their worship in some way or various other.

And through the popularization of Jungian psychology, the the anima, or feminine part of the male psyche, and also the animus, the masculine part of the female psyche, have become household words, and the idea that men have actually eactivities and also feelings and also that womales have no difficulty being hard and logical pervades our culture.

The film industry has actually been well aware of these 2 fads for at least the past few decades, and, I would suggest, has actually aided to fuel them. So why would certainly it all of a sudden go all patriarchal on us? I’m not saying it hasn’t, Ms Boxer is the majority of convincing, I’m simply sayin’ that maybe, by presenting us with all these perfect fathers, the children’s film market is encouraging males to call their inner womale, their emotional, nurturing, intuitive side and also for womales to call their inner man, their logical, assertive, powerful side (Yes, there are many flicks about amazingly solid women). This means our children will have actually not just effective female role models, however also emotionally intact, nurturing, intuitive male duty models.

The Goddess never passed away, she is present in each and also eexceptionally one of us, male and female, as is the God. What better way to carry her ago into our hearts and consciousness than by presenting grieving fathers learning to be both a mommy and a father to their bereft children?

What execute you think? Is our film sector regulated by patriarchal misogynists or new age feminists?

*Carolyn Dever, Death and the Mvarious other From Dickens to Freud: Victorian Fiction and the Anxiety of Origins, 1998.

**Bruno Tettleheim, The Uses of Enchantment, 1976.

***Actually, we can’t blame it all on monotheism. Paganism was turning patriarchal lengthy before Abraham was even a gleam in his father’s eye. But at leastern pagans had actually goddesses.

See more: Not On The Moments Not On The Outside, Not On The Outside, But On The Inside, Strong!

****Merlin Stone, When God Was a Woman, Riane Eisler, The Chalice and also the Blade, Marija Gimbutas, The Civilization of the Goddess, Monica Sjoo, The Great Cosmic Mother: Relearning the Religion of the Earth, Leonard Shlain, The Alphabet vs. the Goddess, and also many even more.