Land Tenure History

Key factors that have shaped UNITED STATE Indian policy and led to the fractured state of Indian land tenure in Indian Counattempt today encompass numerous federal laws and legislative acts. Perhaps the single a lot of terrible federal policy was the General Allotment Act of 1887, additionally called the Dawes Act after Senator Henry Dawes, the Act’s lead proponent.

You are watching: Which of the following best describes the reasons why the dawes act was passed?

History of Allotment

The UNITED STATE federal federal government began the policy of allotting Indian land as early as 1798. Several treaties with Indian tribes had provisions that declared land would be divided among their individual members. After 1871, yet, Congress claimed that no better treaties would certainly be made and also all future dealings through Indians would be conducted via regulation.

Why Allotment?

Tright here were numerous reasons that allotment advocates sustained the policy. First, many kind of of them considered the Indian lifestyle and cumulative use of land also to be communistic and backwards. They likewise saw the individual ownership of private building as a critical component of human being that would give Indian people a factor to stay in one location, cultivate land, neglect the cohesiveness of the people, and also take on the behavior, methods and interests of the American settler population. In addition, many assumed that Indian people had actually as well much land and also they were eager to watch Indian lands opened up for settlement as well as for railroadways, mining, foresattempt and other industries.

General Allotment Act of 1887 (Dawes Act)

The Allotment advocates eventually flourished in convincing the federal federal government to embrace the policy nationally. In 1887, Congress passed the General Allotment Act, which authorized the president (at the time Grover Cleveland) to survey Indian tribal land also and divide the area into allotments for individual Indians and also families. The Allotment Act (additionally recognized as the Dawes Act, named for Senator Henry Dawes of Massachusetts, the Act’s lead proponent) was used to reservations whenever, in the president’s opinion, it was advantageous for certain Indian nations. Members of the schosen tribe or reservation were either offered permission to select pieces of land – usually about 40 to 160 acres in size – for themselves and also their kids, or the tracts were assigned by the agency superintendent. If the amount of reservation land also gone beyond the amount needed for allotment, the federal federal government could negotiate to purchase the land also from the tribes and market it to non-Indian inhabitants. As an outcome, 60 million acres were either ceded outbest or offered to the government for non-Indian homesteaders and corporations as “surplus lands.”

Although the General Allotment Act was the initially major item of law designed to allot Indian bookings throughout the UNITED STATE, many kind of tribes were allotted under special law that was distinct to their tribe or reservation. These acts usually are equivalent to the General Allotment Act however regularly contain distinct provisions.


Origins of the Trust Relationship

Under the plan of allotment, Indian land ownership was not the same as land ownership for various other homesteaders. Non-Indian settlers could market or alienate their land bereason they had actually complete fee simple ownership. Under the General Allotment Act, Indian allottees were asserted “incompetent” to take care of their land affairs and the United States would certainly retain legal title to the land also as trustee for the allottee; Indian allottees just had actually helpful or usufruct title. In various other words, as lengthy as the allotment was held in trust by the federal government, the Indian landholder could use the land but not sell it or lease it without the federal government’s approval. However before, the Act stated that 25 years after the allotment was issued, Indian allottees would certainly be provided finish, fee straightforward ownership of the land. At that allude, the landowner can market or lease it to anyone.

In spite of the original safeguards in place to help Indian people retain their land also, the General Allotment Act led to Indian land also holdings to plunge from 138 million acres in 1887 to 48 million acres by 1934 when allotment ended. This taken place for numerous reasons. First, during the allotment of many appointments, the a lot of productive land was identified as “surplus to Indian needs” and also marketed off to white settlers or business interests. In enhancement, many Indian human being did not come to be the farmers the UNITED STATE government wanted them to be. The General Allotment Act did not carry out for farming education and learning or farming equipment. In enhancement, the allotted land was often inappropriate for farming, and for some Indian teams, intensive farming was culturally unacceptable. Cut off from their livelihoods and their previous means of survival, some Indian world sold their land also after the 25-year trust period bereason they had actually no indicates of sustaining themselves and had actually nothing else to sell.

Amendments to the General Allotment Act also made it simpler for Indian land to pass into non-Indian hands. For instance, in 1902 legislation recognized as the “Dead Indian Act” was passed that permitted Indian landowners to market lands they inherited also if they were still in trust. In 1906, the Burke Act was passed, which authorized the secretary of the interior to decide whether an Indian perboy was “competent” to manage his or her lands. If the Indian person was considered “knowledgeable,” the secretary can take the land also out of trust and the land also would certainly become taxable. The secretary of the inner was authorized to carry out this through or without the expertise and/or versus the wishes of the allottee. Therefore, many Indian human being finished up having actually their land also marketed in tax forclocertain auctions bereason they owed taxes on land also they believed remained in trust. With the Act of May 29, 1908, the secretary of the interior was additionally provided power to market the allotments of deceased Indian landowners if he considered the heirs inexperienced. In the end, 27 million acres of Indian land also were lost as an outcome of these acts.

So a lot Indian land also was passing out of Indian hands that also the U.S. federal government became alarmed. In 1928, a government report entitled “The Problem of Indian Administration” (additionally well-known as the “Merriam Report”) sharply criticized the plan of allotment and the U.S. Indian Service in basic. The report provided undeniable proof of the destructiveness of federal Indian policy and also spurred substantial changes in the federal administration of Indian affairs.

See more: How Many Molecules Of Water Are In One Mole Of Water ? Mass And Volume

Allotment Ends, Challenges Remain

In 1934, the Wheeler-Howard Act (additionally recognized as the Indian Reorganization Act) was passed ending the process of allotment on Indian lands in the contiguous USA. and also ensuring that all remaining trust allotments would certainly continue to be in trust incertainly. It did not, however, proccasion land from passing out of trust once it was inherited by a non-Indian heir or when an allotment owner petitioned the secretary to terminate the trust condition of the allotment or rerelocate constraints upon aliecountry. Furthermore, the Act did not readjust some parts of the General Allotment Act that had actually made the use of allotments significantly challenging among Indian people:

Probates still enhanced fractiocountry with prospering numbers of widespread interemainder holders in each allotmentThe trust device still maintained decision-making authority over the land in the Bureau of Indian Affairs as a far-off and paternalistic landlordLarge percenteras of reservation land were currently organized by non-IndiansThe natural sovereignty of Indian countries was limited to those lands organized in trust

Allotment not only caused 90 million acres of Indian land also to be removed from Indian ownership and also manage, its impact continues to have severe after-effects, such as the significantly fractionated ownership of Indian land title, checkerboard ownership patterns on many kind of bookings and loss of accessibility to crucial spiritual sites, to name simply a couple of.

The allotment of American Indian reservations was a plan put right into impact by many kind of pieces of law. This section gives brief recaps of and also web links to all general allotment regulation, consisting of the General Allotment Act of 1887, its amendments and other connected legislation. In enhancement to regulation that allotted land, also listed is legislation poignant on a multitude of problems developing from allotment, such as leasing, the determination of heirs and also disposal of allotment lands, the powers of the secretary of the inner over allotment lands, and the determicountry of Indian “competency.”