Merit pay is a staple of employee performance monitoring. What are the benefits and also constraints of merit pay, and also how have the right to you usage it to drive your company's success?


Merit pay and catalyst pay are both kinds of pay for performance.

You are watching: What is an advantage of bonuses over merit-based pay plan?

A examine by researchers at the Wisconsin School of Company discovered that:

More than 90% of suppliers use some form of pay for performance.The a lot of prevalent types are merit pay (annual increases) and also bonuses.Both merit and catalyst pay boost employee performance.Bonsupplies have actually a much better influence on performance than merit pay.Performance-based pay has the highest possible affect in tasks wbelow outcomes are conveniently measured.

Bonsupplies and other impetus pay may outperform merit pay bereason of their size. According to the the majority of recent compensation information from Mercer, impetus or promotional pay averaged 9.3% in 2019, while merit pay averaged 2.9%.


Annual merit boosts averaged 2.9% in 2019. Source:

A 10% bonus will certainly grab even more attention than a 3% annual salary bump, also though the 3% compounds year after year. Add to that the underwhelming performance of the standard performance review. Gallup reports they frequently carry out more damage than good, and also the best route forward is much from clear if you want to incentivize employee performance.

Here are some merit pay pros and also cons to think about.

4 advantages of offering merit pay

Merit pay is a staple of employee engagement and performance monitoring. Here are some benefits of consisting of a merit pay setup in your compensation and benefits strategy.

1. Rewards high performers

High performers grow on results, feedback, and also notching wins. They desire to check out the numbers go up, the job come in early, the five-star reviews roll in. Tying their pay to those results demonstrates the value they lug and drives them to keep excelling. To high performers, the annual performance bonus reinforces their idea that their job-related matters, and also you worth it.

2. Connects occupational to results

To carry out great points, you have to aim for them. A merit pay mechanism provides clear missions to work-related towards, keeps employees on track throughout the year, and also rewards them once they accomplish their goals.

3. Retains excellent employees

Merit and also impetus pay enhance employee satisfactivity, engagement, and also retention. They are particularly vital for retaining peak performers. Merit pay is also a key factor in recruitment.

4. Enhances performance

A good merit pay routine provides employees the tools, incentive, and feedearlier to strive for results and innovation. That equates to stronger results and also a more powerful agency.

4 disadvantages of supplying merit pay

Merit pay likewise has actually many kind of drawbacks that have the right to alleviate or also erase its benefits. Here are 4 disbenefits to think about as soon as weighing merit-based compensation.

1. Results aren"t always measurable

While some purposes have the right to be boiled dvery own to measurable vital performance signs (KPIs), many type of aspects of performance are subjective. Soft abilities such as interaction and collaboration are not measurable, yet they"re simply as important to your company"s success as technological competence. Finding objective ways to reward those skills can be complex.

2. Performance is subjective

Employee performance is also harder to effectively quantify and meacertain. All also frequently, employees feel their ratings are arbitrary, inexact, or unfair. Inconsistency from manager to manager deserve to additionally contact the fairness of your device into question.

Many companies have actually addressed this by eliminating numeric ratings from performance evaluations, yet the bottom line still comes dvery own to numbers as soon as you interpret all that feedearlier into merit-based raises.

3. It have the right to produce tunnel vision

Merit pay can encourage employees to focus also tightly on the objectives they"re being rewarded for. This have the right to limit their ability to check out new concepts and develop their complete potential. For example, a shop floor supervisor whose merit rises are tied to productivity might overlook avenues to improve safety or high quality.

4. Rivalry is inevitable

Competition can be healthy and balanced. It can also destroy a team or a department. An annual pilgrimage to Cancun for your peak saleshuman being is good, but employees that miss out on the note may feel cheated. Is their area much less desirable? Are they gaining an also possibility at the ideal leads? Even private performance reviews can end up being a allude of contention if employees compare notes on their raises. We"re only human; coming in second, or tenth, damages.

On the flip side, rewarding poor performers at the same level as various other employees deserve to demotivate high achievers.

Nobody sassist this would be straightforward.

Is merit pay best for your business?

Studies confirm merit pay and also various other PFP programs have the right to enhance employee performance, so, imperfect as it may be, linking pay to performance renders sense. And through 90% of service providers providing annual merit increases, skipping them might damages your capacity to recruit and retain height performers.

So exactly how have the right to you reap the benefits of performance-based pay without cries of unfairness?


Promotional boosts or catalyst pay averaged 9.3% in 2019. Source:

9 merit pay system best practices

Here are finest practices for a merit pay mechanism that will certainly work-related for your company and also staff.

1. Focus on measurable goals

Tying employee purposes to company performance is a prrange tactic for boosting performance and also structure faith in your pay techniques. Use measurable KPIs wright here you deserve to. For instance, rather of rating customer service from "outstanding" to "needs innovation," you could set a bar for positive reviews received or tickets closed within 24 hrs.

Your mechanism will not be perfect — they never before are — yet the even more you have the right to connect performance to measurable agency objectives, the better it will be received.

2. Provide coaching

Are you investing in employee training and development? Employees desire to learn and prosper at job-related. Giving them avenues to upability and also boost is important to helping them accomplish company goals.

3. Give constant feedback

Performance reviews should consist of a cycle of check-ins and feedearlier throughout the year, not just an annual summit. Employees who obtain frequent feedago are more most likely to remain on track and also to feel their reviews are fair.

4. Train managers

Managers additionally require coaching and also development. Many front-line supervisors are advocated right into those positions with bit endure in performance management, yet they"re the foundation of your regime. Make certain your leaders are equipped to use your pay regime repeatedly and also sensibly to drive their teams" performance.

5. Calibrate your pay system

If your pay device is too complex, it will certainly be cumbersome to provide and also confusing to employees. Focus on a handful of goals to affix to compensation.

Your pay scales and also raises likewise need to be finely calibrated: differentiated sufficient to reward high performance, yet not so broad as to feel unfair.

6. Involve employees

Involving employees in setting goals and KPIs for their positions motivates buy-in to your performance monitoring system. It"s also a good strategic exercise.

7. Build in flexibility

As with any type of human reresource (HR) practice, your device requirements sufficient adaptability to allow for manager discretion.

8. Consider alternate plans

Some suppliers have applied innovative variable compensation plans in lieu of straightforward merit awards. Here are some examples from a current Society for Human Reresource Management (SHRM) symposium:

Annual merit raises plus quarterly bonusesSet salary increases based upon company-wide performanceNo merit boosts, with regular market adjustments to pay as warrantedVariable pay based upon task level, from 35% to policemans to 8% for support staffIncentive awards whenever before employees go over and also beyond

9. Use software

Using HR software such as Zoho People to carry out pay and performance monitoring can conserve supervisors and HR staff time on regimen paperoccupational. It can also enhance the accuracy and fairness of your performance evaluation mechanism. Software makes it simple to sfinish out surveys and also gather feedago properly.

HR software have the right to additionally carry out workpressure analytics and also other insights to indevelop your pay techniques.

See more: What Does Ascendant Energy Do In Destiny, Ascendant Energy

Merit pay has its merits

For all the talk about ditching performance reviews and annual merit boosts, it"s tough to imagine a mechanism to connect pay through performance that does not depend on some variation of these time-tested techniques. But those devices are yours to adapt to fit your company"s distinctive culture and goals. The key is to gain input from your staff, look for new principles, and keep on tweaking till your mechanism truly serves your employees and your company.