I should prove the cube root is irrational. I adhered to the proof for the square root of $2$ but I ran into a trouble I wasn"t certain of. Here are my steps:

By contradiction, say $ sqrt<3>2$ is rationalthen $ sqrt<3>2 = frac ab$ in the lowest create, wright here $a,b in slrfc.orgbbZ, b eq 0$$2b^3 = a^3 $$b^3 = fraca^32$therefore, $a^3$ is eventherefore, $2mid a^3$,therefore, $2mid a$$exists k in slrfc.orgbbZ, a = 2k$ sub in: $2b^3 = (2k)^3$$b^3 = 4k^3$, therefore $2|b$ Contradiction, $a$ and $b$ have actually prevalent element of two

My difficulty is with action 6 and 7. Can I say that if $2mid a^3$ , then $2mid a$. If so, I"m gonna need to prove it. How??


*

*

This is not, probably, the many convincing or explanatory proof, and this definitely does not answer the question, but I love this proof.

You are watching: Prove cube root of 3 is irrational

Suppose that $ sqrt<3>2 = frac p q $. Then $ 2 q^3 = p^3 $. This implies $ q^3 + q^3 = p^3 $. The last equation has actually no nontrivial integer solutions as a result of Fermat"s Last Theorem.


*

If $p$ is prime, and also $pmid a_1a_2cdots a_n$ then $pmid a_i$ for some $i$.

Now, let $p=2$, $n=3$ and also $a_i=a$ for all $i$.


*

Your proof is fine, once you understand also that step 6 means action 7:

This is simply the truth odd $ imes$ odd $=$ odd. (If $a$ were odd, then $a^3$ would certainly be odd.)

Anymethod, you don"t need to assume that $a$ and $b$ are coprime:

Consider $2b^3 = a^3$. Now count the number of components of $2$ on each side: on the left, you get an number of the create $3n+1$, while on the best you obtain an a number of the develop $3m$. These numbers cannot be equal bereason $3$ does not divide $1$.


*

The Fundapsychological Theorem of Arithmetic tells us that eexceptionally positive integer $a$ has a distinct factorization right into primes $p_1^alpha_1p_2^alpha_2 ldots p_n^alpha_n$.

You have $ 2 mid a^3$, so $2 mid (p_1^alpha_1p_2^alpha_2 ldots p_n^alpha_n)^3 = p_1^3alpha_1p_2^3alpha_2 ldots p_n^3alpha_n$.

Due to the fact that primes are numbers that are just divisible by 1 and also themselves, and also 2 divides one of them, one of those primes (say, $p_1$) have to be $2$.

So we have $2 mid a^3 = 2^3alpha_1p_2^3alpha_2 ldots p_n^3alpha_n$, and also if you take the cube root of $a^3$ to acquire $a$, it"s $2^alpha_1p_2^alpha_2 ldots p_n^alpha_n$. This has actually a element of 2 in it, and therefore it"s divisible by 2.


For the sake of contradiction, assume $ sqrt<3>2$ is rational.

We have the right to therefore say $ sqrt<3>2 = a/b$ wright here $a,b$ are integers, and $a$ and $b$ are coprime (i.e. $a/b$ is totally reduced).

2=$a^3/b^3$

$2b^3 = a^3$

Hence $a$ is an also integer.

Like all also integers, we deserve to say $a=2m$ where $m$ is an integer.

2$b^3 = (2m)^3$

$2b^3 = 8m^3$

$b^3 = 4m^3$

So $b$ is likewise even. This completes the contradiction wright here we assumed $a$ and also $b$ were coprime.

Hence, $ sqrt<3>2$ is irrational.


A various technique is making use of polynomials and the rational root theorem. Because $sqrt<3>2$ is a root of $f(x)=x^3-2$, it is enough to display that if $f(x)$ has no rational roots, then $sqrt<3>2$ is irrational.

By the rational root theorem, possible roots are $x=pm 1$ or $x=pm2$

Next off inspect that $f(-2)$, $f(-1)$, $f(1)$, $f(2)$ ,$ ot= 0$

$$f(-2)=-10 ot= 0$$$$f(-1)=-3 ot= 0$$$$f(1)=-1 ot= 0$$$$f(2)=6 ot= 0$$

So since none of these feasible rational roots are equal to zero, $sqrt<3>2$ is irrational.


Thanks for contributing an answer to slrfc.orgematics Stack Exchange!

Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid

Asking for aid, clarification, or responding to other answers.Making statements based on opinion; ago them up with references or individual endure.

Use slrfc.orgJax to format equations. slrfc.orgJax reference.

See more: Think And Grow Rich: A Black Choice By: Dr Dennis Kimbro, Think And Grow Rich: A Black Choice

To learn even more, watch our tips on creating excellent answers.


Post Your Answer Discard

By clicking “Message Your Answer”, you agree to our regards to service, privacy policy and also cookie plan


Not the answer you're looking for? Browse various other concerns tagged discrete-slrfc.org proof-confirmation or ask your very own question.


Prove the adhering to statement by proving its contrapositive: if $r$ is irrational, then $ r ^ frac 1 5 $ is irrational
website design / logo design © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.10.1.40358


Your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exadjust have the right to store cookies on your device and also disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy.