*
AuthorTopic: Which building is right: “My brother and I…” or “I and also my brother…”? (Read 1309 times)




You are watching: My brother and me vs my brother and i

Joe CarilloAdministratorHero MemberPosts: 4278Karma: +88/-2
*

*



See more: How Are Most Adjectives Changed Into Adverbs ? Forming Adverbs From Adjectives

Both “My brother and I…” and “I and also my brother…” are grammatically correct. In polite society, however, it is thought about great develop or good etiquette for such first-perkid declarative sentences to mention the identification of the other subject first ahead of that of the first-perchild speaker. So the preferred polite building and construction is “My brother and I saw watch a movie last night” quite than “I and my brother saw watch a movie last night.” Your recollection that your college teacher prescribed this bereason “the second perkid or topic is more essential than the speaker” isn’t specifically best. The comparative prestige or social station of the entities has gained nothing to do via the preferential usage; it’s sindicate a socio-cultural norm in English-speaking cultures that may not necessarily apply in non-English-speaking societies.On the issue of whether to use a gerund or infinitive in this sentence, “My brvarious other and also I love (collecting, to collect) stamps,” I think “love” is just one of those verbs that allow both the gerund form and the infinitive form to be the object verbal in such constructions; for this reason, you are appropriate to pick the building “My brvarious other and also I love collecting stamps” (gerund phrase as straight object of the verb “love”) yet your colleague was best as well in picking “My brother and also I love to collect stamps” (infinitive phrase as straight object of the verb “love”). It’s really a toss-up between the 2. Be forewarned though that this interchangecapability in between gerunds and also infinitives as straight objects doesn’t use to all verbs in general. The alternative in between a gerund and an infinitive counts on the wanted shade of meaning, and also I need to say that this alternative is a rather complex thing. To acquire an excellent manage and appreciation of the bases for this choice, inspect out my essay in the Forum on the topic, “The option between gerunds and infinitives.” I have put together the 4 ground rules in English grammar for intelligently making that choice.Good luck!IMPORTANT READING:“The alternative in between gerunds and infinitives”
*